Well, it’s been two years since I did my “epic” match-up of
the four Superman reboots. While it wasn't completely perfect, I thought it was a nice challenge. For those who don’t know, I basically put the four Superman rebooted origins (Man of Steel, Birthright,Secret Origin, and New 52) beside one another to see which origin was the best.
It was kind of based off the Nostalgia Critic’s “Old vs. New” segment. It took
a while, but I got through it. Afterwards, I tried to think of other things I
could do this to. It took a while to come up with some things. Green Lantern’s
origins were one of the first things to pop into my mind.
In 1989, DC decided to do a retelling of Hal Jordan’s
origins in a miniseries called Green Lantern: Emerald Dawn. Its sequel, Green
Lantern: Emerald Dawn 2, actually takes place during towards the end of Emerald
Dawn. It was worked on by Jim Owsley (aka Christopher Priest), Gerard Jones,
Keith Giffen, M.D. Bright, and Romeo Thangal. I actually talked about both
mini-series a long time ago. I still think both stories are pretty good. In
2007, DC decided to do another retelling of Hal’s origins that tied heavily
into Geoff Johns’ run on Green Lantern. Instead of a mini-series, the origin
was featured in Green Lantern #29-35. Geoff Johns, Ivan Reis, and Oclair Albert
reintroduced us to a young Hal. It is also pretty good.
While Hal Jordan isn’t my favorite character (or my favorite
GL), he’s still a nice character and is a major part of the Justice League.
Plus, his origin stories are pretty good. Still, which one is the best? My plan
is to look at the major features of each origin and see what was done better. I
only have about eight things to look at, so this won’t take long. I’ll look at
things like the heroes, villains, supporting characters, art, and overall
story. I’ll now start off with the main man of the origins, Hal Jordan.





